Article 32/2023

What are the factors to be taken into account to determine the period of reinstatement?

What are the factors to be taken into account to determine the amount of back pay?

_____________________________________

In Moroveke v Talane NO (2021) 32 SALLR 34 (CC), the constitutional court recently had to deal with
providing answers to both the aforesaid questions, and dealt with the matters as follows:

reinstatement?

  • the period of reinstatement should take into account the period of unemployment since the date of the dismissal that is substantively unfair or substantively and procedurally unfair
  • the reinstatement order period should not be such to either enrich or impoverish the employee, but its purpose should be to restore the employment relationship

(see, further, Toyota v CCMA (2016) 37 ILJ 313 (CC); Mediterranean Textile Mills v SACTWU (2012) 33 ILJ 160 (LAC); Sibiya v SAPS (2022) 33 SALLR 28 (LAC))

back pay?

  • the purpose of back pay is to make good the employee’s loss and not to punish the employer
  • back pay thus represents the difference between the amount the employee, who has been substantively unfairly dismissed or substantively and procedurally unfairly dismissed, earned before the date of dismissal when compared to the period of unemployment – it is thus possible that reinstatement could be for a period of 24 months, but back pay could be for a shorter or longer time period, depending, in both instances, on different factors, namely, the period of unemployment and the amount of loss

(see, further, Davids v Boland Rugby [2012] ZALCCT 69; Le Monde Luggage v Dunn NO (2007) 28 ILJ 2238 (LAC))

April 25, 2025

How did the labour court, in Simunye Workers Forum v Registrar of Labour Relations, per Van Niekerk J, in terms of s111(3) of the LRA, on appeal, deal with the decision of the registrar refusing the application of the aforesaid trade union?

April 20, 2025

How do procedural fairness requirements relating to dismissals based upon misconduct (as well as incapacity), contained in the 1995 LRA, differ from the environment that preceded this Act?

April 15, 2025

The purpose of this article is to, firstly, analyse the latest developments in the above regard and, secondly, to determine some of the principles so applicable to each potential type of suspension.