Article 06/2021

Labour Edge

What are the five differences between a claim in terms of the LRA and the BCEA, recently identified by the labour appeal court, in Pilanesberg Platinum Mines (Pty) Ltd v Ramabulana (2019) 30 SALLR 165 (LAC)?

These differences are as follows:

  1. in terms of the LRA, the relief is for reinstatement, whereas, in terms of the BCEA, it is for specific performance;
  2. in terms of the LRA, compensation is a statutory relief, whereas, in terms of the BCEA, an employee must prove the damages suffered before obtaining monetary relief;
  3. in terms of the BCEA, the onus is on the employee, whereas, in terms of the LRA, the onus is on the employer;
  4. in terms of the BCEA, the claim is a contractual one where the onus is on the employee to prove the quantum of damages – it is a misconception that such damages are the amount the employee would have earned until retirement; and
  5. because contractual disputes, in terms of the BCEA, are civil matters, there is no reason why costs should not follow the result, whereas, in terms of s162 of the LRA, costs are awarded according to the requirements of law and fairness.

 

September 5, 2024

In assessing if reinstatement is fitting after CCMA deems dismissal in a fixed-term contract unfair, what factors guide this determination?

August 29, 2024

Is a binding agreement between a retrenching employer and the alternative employer required for the above section to be applicable and what role does the retrenching employer have to play in arranging alternative employment for such section to be applicable?

August 22, 2024

An accountant at a municipality faced dismissal for attempting to access the account. Reinstated after appealing to the bargaining council, new charges of dishonesty and IT policy breach led to another dismissal.