Edition,May 2024

1. CORRECT USER NAME AND PASSWORD

If, for any reason, you are encountering problems with accessing the SOUTH AFRICAN LABOUR LAW REPORTS (‘SALLR’) website on www.sallr.co.za ,
kindly contact Taryn van der Merwe on 041 373 4322 or pa@vanzylrudd.co.za .

2. LABOUR COURT, LABOUR APPEAL COURT, HIGH COURT AND SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

2.1 Since Newsletter 4 of 2024, Van Zyl, Rudd & Associates has published 53.

2.2 The index to these judgments is attached hereto for ease of reference.

Kindest regards
The SALLR team

INDEX 5

2024

CONSTITUTIONAL COURT

COCA COLA BEVERAGES AFRICA PTY LTD V COMPETITION COMMISSION AND ANOTHER 2024 35 SALLR 112 CC CCT 192 22

FUJITSU SERVICES CORE PTY LTD V SCHENKER SOUTH AFRICA PTY LTD 2023 34 SALLR 343 CC CCT 32 22

MUDAU V MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES PENSION FUND AND OTHERS 2023 34 SALLR 344 CC CCT 142 22

REGENESYS MANAGEMENT PTY LTD TA REGENESYS V ILUNGA AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 113 CC CCT 220 22

HIGH COURT
GAS GIANTS CC AND ANOTHER V ECONOMIC FREEDOM FIGHTERS AND OTHERS 2023 34 SALLR 345 HC 13850 2022

NATIONAL UNION OF METALWORKERS OF SOUTH AFRICA AND OTHERS V SCAW SA PTY LTD 2023 34 SALLR 346 HC 36203 20

VAN WYK AND OTHERS V MINISTER OF EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR 2024 35 SALLR 134 HC 2022 017842

LABOUR APPEAL COURT

ACTING NATIONAL COMMISSIONER FOR THE DEPT OF CORRECTIONAL SERV AND OTHERS V NDARA 2023 34 SALLR 347 LAC CA14 2022

AFRICA ONLINE OPERATIONS MAURITIUS LIMITED V SCANLON AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 114 LAC CA01 2023

ASSOCIATION OF MINEWORKERS AND CONSTRUCTION UNION V UASA AND OTHERS 2023 34 SALLR 348 LAC DA13 2022

ECONOMIC FREEDOM FIGHTERS V BRIGHTSTONE TRADING 3 CC AND OTHERS 2023 34 SALLR 349 LAC JA129 2021

GB ENGINEERING PTY LTD V MBONGO AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 115 LAC JA75 2022

MOBILE TELEPHONE NETWORKS PTY LTD AND OTHERS V CCI SA UMHLANGA PTY LTD 2023 34 SALLR 350 LAC JA12 2023

MURRAY AND ROBERTS CEMENTATION PTY LTD V AMCU OBO DUBE AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 116 LAC JA96 2022

NATIONAL UNION OF METALWORKERS OF SOUTH AFRICA AND OTHERS V NTLOKOSE 2024 35 SALLR 117 LAC JA84 2022

NORTH WEST PROVINCIAL LEGISLATURE AND ANOTHER V NEHAWU OBO 158 MEMBERS 2023 34 SALLR 351 LAC JA17 2022

QUANTUM FOODS PTY LTD V COMMISSIONER H JACOBS NO AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 118 LAC JA85 2022

SACCAWU V MASSMART HOLDING LIMITED AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 119 LAC JA119 2022

SADAN AND ANOTHER V WORKFORCE STAFFING PTY LTD 2023 34 SALLR 352 LAC JA38 23 AND JA39 23

SANLAM LIFE INSURANCE LIMITED V MOGOMATSI AND OTHERS 2023 34 SALLR 353 LAC CA12 2022

THE PASSENGER RAIL AGENCY OF SOUTH AFRICA AND OTHERS V NGOYE AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 120 LAC JA78 21

TORRENTE AND ANOTHER V GRANT MONAGHAN AND ASSOCIATES INC 2024 35 SALLR 121 LAC JA 45 23 AND JA 25 23

LABOUR COURT

AFRICAN MEDICAL ASS TRADE UNION OBO DR H RIKHOTSO V MEC DEPT OF HEALTH LIMPOPO PROVINCE 2023 34 SALLR 354 LC J1773 2022

AMCU OBO MEMBERS V ABERDARE CABLES PTY LTD AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 122 LC P135 2021

ANGLO AMERICAN COAL SOUTH AFRICA V CCMA AND OTHERS 2023 34 SALLR 355 LC JR 2115 20

COETZEE AND OTHERS V MEC FOR THE DEPT OF HEALTH WESTERN CAPE PROVINCIAL GOV AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 123 LC C 276 2021

CONNOR V LEXISNEXIS PTY LTD 2024 35 SALLR 124 LC P18 24

DETAWU OBO TSHWILI V BIDWEST SERVICES PTY LTD TA BIDWEST PRESTIGE CLEANING SERVICES 2023 34 SALLR 356 LC C725 2021

EPHRAIM MOGALE LOCAL MUNICIPALITY V HLONGWANE NO AND ANOTHER 2023 34 SALLR 357 LC JR1888 2019

EPIBIZ PTY LTD V CCMA AND OTHERS 2023 34 SALLR 358 LC JR616 18

FETAKGOMO GREATER TUBATSE LOCAL MUNICIPALITY V SALGBC AND OTHERS 2023 34 SALLR 359 LC JR1832 19

HOLLYWOOD SPORTSBROOK GAUTENG V CCMA AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 125 LC JR2519 21

LA FOY V DEPT OF JUSTICE AND CONSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT AND OTHERS 2023 34 SALLR 360 LC J1952 2017

MAKHONJWA V DIRECTOR GENERAL OF THE DEPT OF JUSTICE AND CONSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT 2023 34 SALLR 361 LC JR 998 19

MASHIYA V MINISTER OF JUSTICE AND CORRECTIONAL SERVICES AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 126 LC JR2740 13

NATIONAL LOTTERIES COMMISSION V MAFONJO AND ANOTHER 2023 34 SALLR 362 LC JR48 2020

NATIONAL UNION OF METAL WORKERS OF SOUTH AFRICA AND ANOTHER V CCMA AND OTHERS 2023 34 SALLR 363 LC PR10 22

NUMSA OBO MEMBERS V SAA TECHNICAL PTY LTD 2023 34 SALLR 364 LC JS30 2022

NUPSAW OBO LUTENDO AND OTHERS V CCMA AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 127 LC J 2086 20 AND JR 2111 20

RAMTHLAKGWE V MODIMOLLE MOOKGOPONG LOCAL MUNICIPALITY AND ANOTHER 2023 34 SALLR 365 LC JS562 23

REDELINGHUYS V ADAPT IT PTY LTD 2023 34 SALLR 366 LC C199 2019

SAMANCOR CHROME LTD WESTERN CHROME MINES V WILLEMSE AND OTHERS 2023 34 SALLR 367 LC JR312 2020

SAMWU V MINISTER OF COOPERATIVE GOVERNANCE AND TRADITIONAL AFFAIRS AND ANOTHER 2024 35 SALLR 128 LC J 945 2023

SEOKWANE V BIDVEST PRESTIGE CLEANING SERVICES PTY LTD 2024 35 SALLR 129 LC JS 1040 20

SIMUNYE WORKERS FORUM V REGISTRAR OF LABOUR RELATIONS 2023 34 SALLR 368 LC J1375 2022

SMALL ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT AGENCY V CCMA AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 130 LC JR52 2021

SOUTH AFRICAN CUSTODIAL MANAGEMENT PTY LTD AND ANOTHER V UPSCO OBO MAKATU AND OTHERS 2023 34 SALLR 369 LC JS38 318

STRYDOM V ARCELORMITTAL SOUTH AFRICA 2024 35 SALLR 131 LC J 1764 2023

SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL

MEC FOR EDUCATION KWAZULUNATAL V SINGH 2023 34 SALLR 370 SCA 1188 2021

MHLONTLO LOCAL MUNICIPALITY AND OTHERS V NGCANGULA AND ANOTHER 2024 35 SALLR 132 SCA 1154 2022

SAMWU NATIONAL PROVIDENT FUND V DIHLABENG LOCAL MUNICIPALITY AND OTHERS 2023 34 SALLR 371 SCA 65 2022

SAMWUMED V CITY OF EKURHULENI AND OTHERS 2024 35 SALLR 133 SCA 1297 2022